Book Review: Check & Mate by Ali Hazelwood

 


Book Review: Check & Mate by Ali Hazelwood

by The Book Pup on March 21, 2026

Blurb (on Goodreads):

Mallory Greenleaf is done with chess. Every move counts nowadays. After the sport led to the destruction of her family four years earlier, Mallory's focus is on her mom, her sisters, and the dead-end job that keeps the lights on. That is, until she begrudgingly agrees to play in one last charity tournament and inadvertently wipes the board with notorious "Kingkiller" Nolan Sawyer: current world champion and reigning bad boy of chess.


Nolan's loss to an unknown rook-ie shocks everyone—especially Mallory. What's even more confusing? His desire to cross pawns again. What kind of gambit is Nolan playing? The smart move would be to walk away. Resign. Game over. But Mallory's victory opens the door to sorely needed cash prizes and, despite everything, she can't help feeling drawn to the enigmatic strategist....


As she rockets up the ranks, Mallory struggles to keep her family safely separated from the game that wrecked it in the first place. And as her love for the sport she so desperately wanted to hate begins to rekindle, Mallory quickly realizes that the games aren't only on the board, the spotlight is hotter than she imagined, and the competition can be fierce(-ly attractive. And intelligent...and infuriating...)

My Summary:

Mallory Greenleaf swore off chess after it tore her family apart. Now she's eighteen, holding her family together on a dead-end job income, and absolutely not thinking about chess — until one charity tournament changes everything. 

When she accidentally beats the world's number one ranked player, Nolan Sawyer, the door to prize money she desperately needs swings open. What follows is a story about returning to something you love and lost, navigating family, and the slow, inevitable pull toward someone who challenges you in every way.

My Review

I picked this one up as an enemies-to-lovers chess romance and I was NOT fully prepared for how much I would enjoy it. 🌸♟️ Check & Mate is a 4-star read for me, it had all the ingredients of a 5-star, and in many ways it delivered beautifully, but a few things kept it from reaching that top spot. Let me break it all down. 🦊✨

Let's start with Mallory, because she deserves her flowers. 🌸 I genuinely liked her as a protagonist. She's not flashy or dramatic, she's the kind of girl who is quietly holding everything together and refusing to let anyone see the cracks. Eighteen years old, essentially running a household, sacrificing her own future for her family, and doing it without making it her whole personality. That kind of quiet resilience is so compelling to me, and Mallory had it in spades. 🐾

And NOLAN. 🌙 The brooding, genius, world-champion-of-chess MMC. He is the perfect love interest, mysterious and competitive on the surface, but with layers and warmth underneath that slowly come out the more time he spends with Mallory. The romance between them is well-written, genuinely well-paced for the most part, and has that delicious push-and-pull tension that makes rivals-to-lovers so satisfying. I was rooting for them the whole way through. 🦋💚

Now — the third act breakup. 😤 You know the one. The dreaded miscommunication conflict that exists purely to create drama right before the happy ending. Listen, I understand why authors do it. I do. But when a conflict could be resolved with one honest conversation and instead gets dragged out... I notice. I always notice. It didn't ruin the romance for me, but it did make me roll my eyes a little. 🦉

Let me talk about something that genuinely bothered me though: Oz. 🌲 There are moments in this book where Oz essentially "pep talks" Mallory back into chess, except what he's actually doing is being pretty harsh and condescending. And the narrative frames it as helpful and effective. But I sat there reading it like... that wasn't a pep talk. That was just being mean. Mallory is going through something real and difficult, and roasting her is not the same as supporting her. The fact that it supposedly worked rubbed me the wrong way, because it normalized that kind of "tough love" as motivational when really it was just unkind. 😕

The sister dynamics were fascinating, and a little inconsistent. 🦊 Darcy, the youngest, is genuinely lovable throughout most of the book. But after Mallory quits chess before the world championship? Darcy shuts her out completely, suddenly cold and distant toward the sister who has been sacrificing everything for her. It felt jarring and honestly a little unfair to Mallory's character. And then near the end, it resolves as if nothing happened. 🌙

And then there's Sabrina. 🐱 Here's the thing: Sabrina as a bratty, screen-addicted, perpetually ungrateful teenager is actually written BEAUTIFULLY. It felt like an actual teenager. I appreciated how authentic that characterization was. Which is exactly why her sudden personality shift near the end felt so unearned. One moment she's thorny and difficult, the next she's sweet and understanding, and no real work was done to earn that transition. It had "author tying up loose ends" written all over it, and those kinds of rushed resolutions always take me out of the story a little. 🥀

Speaking of rushed, the ending overall moved too fast for my taste. ⚡ After a book that mostly paced itself really well, the final stretch felt like it was sprinting to the finish line. All the threads got tied up, everyone landed happily, and it was sweet, genuinely sweet, and I'm not complaining about the happy ending itself. But I wanted to BREATHE in it a little more. A few more pages. A little more room to settle into the resolution before it was over. 🌸

BUT. And this is a big but. 🦊✨ I love chess. And this book made me love reading about chess. The competitive world Hazelwood builds around the game, the tournament atmosphere, the strategy and intensity, it was so fun and immersive, and I think even readers who know nothing about chess will find themselves drawn in. That's genuinely impressive. Bonus points for also weaving in the very real issue of sexism in competitive chess, it adds a layer of depth that elevates the story beyond a simple romance. ♟️🌟

Check & Mate is an entertaining, warm, swoony read with a great FMC and an even better MMC. It started as a 5-star in my heart and landed at 4 — but a solid 4 star. 🐾💚

4/5 pawprints 🐾🐾🐾🐾

You can find the book on Goodreads here!

Who I think this book is for: Fans of rivals-to-lovers romance 🔥, readers who love a quiet but resilient FMC 🌸, anyone who wants a clean YA romance with real emotional depth, chess lovers and chess novices alike ♟️, and anyone who needs a warm, feel-good read that still has some teeth to it! 🦊✨

⚠️ Content Note: This is a clean read with no on-page spice! There is implied sexual content (off-page), as well as themes of chronic illness, financial hardship, and family stress. Perfectly appropriate for teens and up. 🌙

Cheers, and happy reading!

The Book Pup 🐾

P.S. Nolan Sawyer has set a new standard for MMCs and I will not be taking questions at this time. ♟️🌙✨

The Book Pup

🐾 Hi, I’m the pup behind the books! Stick around for thoughtful reviews, themed book lists, and a wagging tail’s worth of bookish joy! 📚🐶

Post a Comment

✨🐾 Got a bookish thought?
Leave a comment below! (if it contains spoilers, please mention that). 📚✨

Previous Post Next Post